Bill Maher Says The NFL Is A Commie Lovefest

The United States might be the epicenter of free-market capitalism, but pinkos rule the playing field.

With the Super Bowl just a couple days away--and well over 100 million Americans expected to tune in--let us now pause to reflect on what makes football so great.

Socialism.

That’s Bill Maher’s take, anyway, and he almost has us convinced. Check out this nice little animation of Maher reading a short essay on the topic, from his forthcoming book The New New Rules: A Funny Look at How Everybody but Me Has Their Head Up Their Ass (Penguin, 2012). British motion graphics designer Fraser Davidson did the art direction and animation:

Let’s consider the evidence: The NFL takes money from the richest teams and redistributes it to the poorer ones. Profits from television, the league’s largest source of revenue, get dumped into a pot and divided evenly between the 32 teams. Whoever happens to win the Super Bowl gets the last pick in the draft. In other words, the NFL is rigged so that no single team can dominate year after year. As Maher says, that’s “what the Republicans would call punishing success.”

Maher’s basic point is that all this pinko sharing levels the playing field: Each team has just as much of a shot of making the Super Bowl as the next team, whether you play in the biggest, richest city in America or a “sleepy little town on the banks of the fuck-if-I-know river,” which is to say, Green Bay.

There’s something deeply, almost sentimentally satisfying about the argument, but it does overlook one or two things. Part of the NFL’s much-vaunted parity owes as much to chance as it does to wealth distribution. In a 16-game season, a good team can torpedo its season with a few bad plays. Likewise, a so-so team can score a couple unexpected touchdowns when they need them, sneak into the playoffs, and--who knows?--maybe even make the Super Bowl (see: this year’s New York Giants).

The bigger problem here is that Maher is giving us a weird version of socialism, one in which the workers, ultimately, get screwed. The upshot of the NFL’s efforts to supposedly level the playing field (a salary cap here, a wage scale there) is that the owners pay the players--the people who do the actual work--far less than they would earn on a more open market. Sure, the system has socialist tendencies. But really it’s just socialism for the mega-rich.

Add New Comment

9 Comments

  • John Riecke

    If some teams fail to make it every year, with almost the same reaources as all the others, then that speaks poorly of their management. Imagine that, holding the leadership accountable for their mistakes instead of blaming workers.

  • Mr Economist

    Maher doesn't mention TV revenues are subsidized because US gives broadcasters frequencies for free, and states and cities give away billions in tax revenues. Maybe, that is crony capitalism more so than socialism.

  • N.C.

    Yeah, but that has far more to do with coaching and upper management than anything else.  The perennial favorites are Green Bay, New England, Pittsburgh, and New Orleans.  Pitt and New England have the Krafts and the Rooneys, GB is a publicly owned organization, and New Orleans has had Sean Payton for the last 5 years.  The Giants make it due more to the coach than any other reason.  If Coughlin isn't there I don't think they make it to the playoffs this year.  Let's not forget this team got embarrassed twice by the Skins.   But, anyways, my overarching point is that in order to have success in the NFL you need to have commitment to a coach by a strong upper management.  When was the last time the Cowboys, Raiders, Redskins, Bucs, or Jags were relevant?  Compare that to the Lions the last few years when the cleaned house and made a clear commitment to improving the organization. 

  • Stanley

    It also overlooks the fact that the players that make up the teams in the NFL all have the same mindset, a common goal, and the innate drive to be successful at the expense of those on the other team.  Also, in the NFL if you don't perform, you get CUT!!!

  • Curtis

    Mÿ friênd's stêp-sistêr mâkês $38/hr ôn thê intêrnêt. Shê hâs bêên ôût ôf â jôb fôr 6 mônths bût lâst mônth hêr incômê wâs $1722 jûst wôrking ôn thê intêrnêt fôr â fêw hôûrs. Gô tô this wêb sitê ând rêâd môrê.... Lazy­Cash10.c­o­m