Moneyball 2.0: How Missile Tracking Cameras Are Remaking The NBA

A new camera system is adding a whole new level of analytics to basketball. We talk to insiders using it.

The technology was originally developed to track missiles. Now, SportVU systems hang from the catwalks of 10 NBA arenas, tiny webcams that silently track each player as they shoot, pass, and run across the court, recording each and every move 25 times a second. SportVU can tell you not just Kevin Durant’s shooting average, but his shooting average after dribbling one vs. two times, or his shooting average with a defender three feet away vs. five feet away. SportVU can actually consider both factors at once, plus take into account who passed him the ball, how many minutes he’d been on the court, and how many miles he’d run that game already.

It’s big data in a relatively small pool, and it has the potential to impact everything about basketball, from how it’s coached, to how it’s recruited—even to how we calculate a player’s worth. Sportvision, another sports data collection system based on the same underlying big data idea, has already massively impacted baseball since it came into play in 2006. Now SportVU is generating more basketball data than anyone ever has. And its potential has only begun to be tapped—health care researcher Kirk Goldsberry, who recently wowed the stats geeks at MIT Sloan Sports Analytics Conference with his spatial analysis to determine the best shooters, has begun mining SportVU’s data for new insights. But only 10 teams in the NBA are currently using SportVU. Four of them made the playoffs. One even made it to the finals: The Oklahoma City Thunder.

You could call SportVU the new Moneyball, but that would probably sell SportVU short. “What’s interesting about the Moneyball analogy is that they were using data everybody else had and putting a new twist on it," says Brian Kopp, a vice president at Stats, the company that owns SportVU. "We’re doing that, but also entering into the equation data no one had before. It’s almost Moneyball Plus.” Stats pretty much owns the IP on player stats across sports. Whether it’s the NBA or the NFL that you’re reading about on ESPN or CBS, all those player metrics are being provided by Stats (which is oddly enough, half owned by News Corp and AP). And what they don’t track themselves, they license exclusively from the pro sports themselves.

Kevin Durant’s closely guarded attempts happen all over the court …
… but he actually makes his shots in only a few select areas.

But technology has been getting smarter. A few years back, Stats realized the importance of securing the future technologies in stats tracking, so they acquired an Israeli company called SportVU, that had already repurposed military tracking technology for use in international soccer. “It was an offensive and defensive play,” Kopp says. “The defensive was, another company could automate what we did. The offensive was, we can collect all sorts of new data.”

Simultaneously, this shifted Stats’ relationship with the industry overnight. Whereas they’d once paid leagues for their data, Stats began approaching the teams themselves to supply it. They converted SportVU to work in the NBA—it’s currently the only professional U.S. sport offering they have, though they’ve dabbled in NFL development—and for a fee, they offered to place six tiny, webcam-like cameras in stadium rafters, connected to a laptop. Each game, an operator would just need to show up to calibrate the system (tell the cameras which player was which), and they’d have access to massive amounts of new data.

Kevin Durant’s open shot attempts …
… don’t really line up to his open-shot makes.

Their system captures the X/Y coordinates of all the players and refs—along with the X/Y/Z (3-D) coordinates of the ball—25 times every second (or 72,000 times a game). Algorithms take into account all sorts of variables to keep the system accurate, from the lines on the court to the reflections of flashing billboards. Another layer of software at a central server puts this raw data together into something meaningful. Information as specific as player ball touches and dribbles can be calculated within 60 seconds of being spotted by SportVU cams. Stats can generate these values in simple, automated reports.

And then there’s a third layer of what’s going on: a layer of deep connections. NBA staffs have access to all their own raw data (think huge spreadsheets), and in an information sharing agreement, they have access to everyone else’s raw data, too. That means every team can mine all of the information collected in 10 courts worth of home games across the NBA. This layer is where the teams get very quiet about what’s really going on. Because if sports are about getting an edge, no one wants to broadcast any edge they’ve discovered.

One insider offered several comparisons in the tech world—from Google leveraging big data to choose between 50 shades of blue, to Target knowing, by a customer’s shopping habits alone, whether she was newly pregnant, and customizing the experience for her. But how do font colors and diaper coupons relate to paint penetration and high efficiency play? For some, it’s about separating elite skills from the just sub elite, then rolling that into player evaluations. Maybe we can all agree on the best rebounder in the NBA from their grabs per game. But who is the second best rebounder if several people are tied in stats? And how much better is the best rebounder from the second best? Is that one skill elite enough to offset other weaknesses?

Russell Westbrook’s attempts after five dribbles: A little wild.

A perfect example of this principle is in how SportVU can track assists. Traditionally, the NBA will award a player with the assist if they pass the ball to a player who immediately scores a field goal. It’s a human calculation, a judgement call based more on feel than science (much like a foul). Aside from clear issues of accurate counts, think about everything that generalized "assists" stat misses: What if the best passer in the world is on a team of people who can’t shoot? They’re making the correct play but getting no credit because they’re surrounded by mediocrity. But put this playmaker on a good team, and that team might excel.

SportVU can track these potential assists, and even track the person who passes it to the person who makes the assist. Now scale this level of assessment to every single skill in basketball, and our view of players could change as we know it. But if there’s one flaw the insiders I spoke to agreed upon, it was SportVU’s huge limitation: not that SportVU could generate too much data, but that it didn’t have enough. The fact that only 10 out of 30 NBA teams currently participate is hugely limiting to the product, even if those 10 teams technically record some information on the other 20 teams at all of their home games, and even if SportVU can see things that humans can’t.

For Kopp and Stats, selling the system to the remaining two-thirds of the NBA is the challenge for the foreseeable future. On one hand, deeper data seems inevitable—and no one is disagreeing that SportVU has incredible potential with deep data—on the other, with no teams all that interested in sharing how they’re potentially innovating with that data, it’s making his job no easier. “I know for a fact some of those teams are using it quite a bit. They don’t tell me exactly what they’re doing with it. Some teams are fairly open and they ask for our help. Others are very secretive,” Kopp says. “Because, for a while, it is all about how you’re using it. Once they figure out something they think is meaningful, they don’t want anyone to get a whiff of it.” Move along, nothing to see here! Except, maybe, everything.

Add New Comment

40 Comments

  • The Doctor

    Unless I’m mistaken – seem to be missing a few other elements to the “Big
    Data” pool that can help…

     

    1.       Sensors on
    the player – we see this in some soccer teams with devices
    that map their physical energy, heart rate, speed, sweat indicators..

    2.       Sensors in
    the shoe – Nike & Adidas have now added sensor technology to their boots /
    shoes / trainers

    3.       Add to that fluids
    lost + fluids replaced (and what types of fluids during the game) – what gives
    the player more sustained energy, how is their heart rate, speed etc…

    4.       Map this to
    the Sport VU and you now have data on not only the play of each player, but their
    physical performance, agility and stamina – which in US professional sports,
    such as Basketball, Football etc…  being
    multi-billion dollar business would actually give a better understanding of the
    “worth” of a player

     

    Then – comes the fun part – this data can be used / sold / licensed  for “Drinks” promotions / sponsorship, Nike vs
    Adidas in terms of grip and speed of each type of stud and footware construct,
    medical coverage and treatments and most importantly of all: selling  trading of players –
    an older player may on paper look old and tired – these stats could show that
    he or she is not and here is the stats and data that prove it…

     

    Big Data indeed!

  • 74074Donny

     This is fascinating.  I only wonder how long teams will leave this data sharing policy in place.

  • Job Vogel

    Please contact the Dutch soccer association so they can implement this!
    Maybe they will win again after such an analysis.

  • Hkmk23

    People do realize that at the end of the day this is kind of like using gold to make a toilet: Way too much money spent on something that is essentially tall men playing with a leather ball. 

  • kmr

     basketball is a multi-MULTI-million dollar industry.  if this gives a team an advantage that means they get to the finals (or even win) then it more than paid for itself.

  • RealLife

    Interesting that NBA teams spend $ on this type technology.  The next question is, "OK, you got all this data, how can we teach these overpaid idiots how to use it effectively to win games?" It presupposes these guys have brains to use this data when, in reality, they are one missed paycheck away from pimping and selling crack on the street,

  • Jackmouve

    Doesn't have to be the players using it, coaches can use it to put the most effective combinations of players on the floor for a given situation, they can use it to scout potiential free agents, and use it to coach better.

  • Jlangford

    Really? A lot of these guys are very intelligent and give back to help kids from being left in situations where they have to survive by any means possible. What do you do?
    To bad this technology can't help all you snobs who think your so damn special to stop being judgemental bigots and gather data to show how really weak you are as people. God I feel sorry for you people, life must have really sucked growing up for you. How about do something other than hide behind usernames in your parents guest room. Pathetic assholes!

  • Hkmk23

     Absolutely true.It is a bit too much to expect overpaid and self absorbed high school and college dropouts  to understand something related to rocket science literally. I don't think we can expect the NBA to make any generous donations to school/college science programs either.

  • Bob

    Just wait until this is further developed and put on every street corner, maybe in your house.  That way they can implement the pre-crime system...

  • gnubi

    Won't be long before using those stats, probability, and some fancy graphics they don't even have to play the actual game with actual players or pay them actual cash. Computers can work out how the game would probably have gone, then show us a video of what it would've looked like. Software rules!

  • kmr

     ImaHippyBurning, maybe you're the kind of crappy parent that's letting your TV and/or the opinions of professional athletes guide your child's development, I don't know.  But I know my kids get their moral and ethical character from my wife and me so we're not worried about what they do.

  • ImaHippyBurning

    Couldn't agree more! Can't stand convicts in the off season playing a kids game collecting millions while irreversibly helping to destroy moral and ethical character in this country...